Homes by Email

Be the first to see new listings as soon as they hit the market!

Sigrid A. Cottrell

Sigrid A. Cottrell
Crested Butte Realty
Crested Butte, CO

Contact Me

Quick Search

view all




No Max.
Back to Saved Search
Listing 5 out of 886
$3,575,000 For Sale

95 Rutheron #Melton L
Tierra Amarilla, NM 87575

lot: 1374 acres - MLS# 754793 Courtesy of Hayden Outdoors
Property Photo


Melton Lakes Ranch Bordering the Jicarilla Apache Reservation on the north side and Heron State Park on the west, Melton Lakes Ranch, +/- 1374 acres including 15 lakes and ponds and +/-600-acre feet of irrigation, is on the market. Featuring 360 degrees views, this property is the discriminating elk, mule deer and waterfowl ranching paradise. With the water rights being the gold standard today, Melton Lakes Ranch is located in central Rio Arriba County, the nations #1 Boone and Crockett Mule Deer producer since 1960. The ranch is 20 minutes from Chama New Mexico and 90 minutes to Taos and Santa Fe where you can enjoy fantastic dining, shopping and world renown art galleries. Hunting, Land Owner Tags and Recreation World renown for producing the very best and most coveted mule deer in the country and one of the highest elk densities, the Jicarilla Apache Reservation borders the Melton Lakes Ranch on the north for approximately 1/2 mile. As the resident deer and elk are joined by migration and rut, an abundance of cover, food, water and habitat make the ranch a very attractive haven for the game, with numerous trophy elk and deer harvested. The 15 lakes and ponds (up to several acres) are excellent breeding and resting areas for waterfowl and would accommodate trout stocking with aeration quite well. Additionally, the neighboring Chama River and Heron Reservoir offer additional fishing. New Mexico offers some of the nation's most liberal elk and mule deer landowner tag programs, and it's certainly one of Melton Lakes most attractive features. While the ranch has historically drawn 8-10 archery and rifle elk tags that may be utilized from Archery season (September) and Rifle season (October 1 to December), the Unit 4 deer tags are 100% draw for landowners and their guests (please check regulations). New Mexico also offers big game incentive programs for deer and elk, encouraging the landowners who manage their land for game, longer seasons or bonus tag. Turkey, bear, and excellent waterfowl hunting will compliment the hunting opportunities. Water and Water Rights With +/- 600-acre feet of irrigation and 15 lakes & ponds, this ranch is one of the best watered in New Mexico. Cattle, Buffalo, and Hay Production Through drought years, the ranch has carried 250 yearlings (maxed to 400) with hundreds of acres irrigated, depending on how it's managed. The ranch is fully perimeter fenced and cross-fenced to 7 pastures allowing for rotation. Welded working pens compliment the property (see photos). Certified Organic – The Melton Lakes Ranch is certified organic. Mineral Rights restricted, but negotiable. With millions of acres of public recreation nearby, the Chama/Tres Piedras area is highly sought after with few large land holdings available, especially bordering the Jicarilla Apache Reservation. Add in this large amount of deeded water rights and Melton Lakes Ranch is a holding with few comparisons. Melton Lakes Ranch, featuring 15 bodies of water, working pens, and power on two sides, has no other improvements, allowing the buyer to purchase the land and not spend money on improvements they don't care for. Gorgeous building sites, too many to count, allows the new owner to place the home/headquarters of their dreams where they like and to their own specifications. Existing management/caretaker, with a lifetime of ranch management experience, lives nearby and is very interested in continuing, should the buyer be interested. Holdings like the Melton Lakes Ranch are few and far between.


  • Property Type: Mountain, Undeveloped, Agriculture, Multi-Use, Recreational
  • Sub Type: No Residence
  • Listing Status: Active
  • County/Area: Rio Arriba NM County
  • Zip Code: 87575
  • Elementary School: Open Enrollment
  • Middle School: Open Enrollment
  • High School: Open Enrollment
  • Lot Size: 1374 acres
  • View: Mountains, Lake/Pond/Reservoir
  • Waterfront: Lake/Reservoir, Pond, Yes
  • Zoning: Agriculture
  • Area: New Mexico
  • Apx. Irrig. Acres: 100
  • Can Be Divided: Yes
  • Corral Y/N: Yes
  • Current Property Use: Cattle, Ag/Livestock, Recreation, Mountain Recreation, Pasture, Grazing, Irrigated Farmland, Hunting
  • Elevation: 7200
  • Fence: Cross Fence, Pipe, Partial Property
  • Furnished: Unfurnished
  • Improvements/Structures: Corral
  • Internet Service Avail?: Yes
  • Irr. Water Desc/Amnt: 100
  • Irrigation System/Rights: Owned, Deeded Water, Yes
  • Irrigation/Water District: Tba
  • Lot Size/Acreage: 200+ Acres
  • Mineral Rights: Yes
  • Pasture: Yes
  • Possible Property Use: Ag/Livestock, Cattle, Grazing, Hogs, Horses, Hunting, Irrigated Farmland, Mountain Recreation, Pasture, Poultry, Recreation, Residential Single Family, Sheep Ranch
  • Property Description: Borders Public Land, Adjacent To Open Space
  • Street Description/Access: State Highway, County, Private
  • Topography: Level, Rolling
  • Listing Office: Hayden Outdoors
Courtesy of Hayden Outdoors

Sigrid A. Cottrell
Crested Butte Realty

503 6th St Ste #6
Crested Butte, CO 81224
Phone: 970-596-2596


We chose Sigrid Cottrell based on a local recommendation and extensive knowledge of the Crested Butte, Colorado market as we were new to the area. She did not disappoint! Admittedly, we were not the easiest clients to work with as we had a very long "must have" list (to say the least). Sigrid  went way above and beyond throughout the entire process, and that even included setting up short notice appointments with reputable contractors, which in itself was no easy feat. As we worked with her, it soon became apparent she was more concerned that we find the right property versus her profiting from her commission on the sale. Sigrid's professionalism, enthusiastic and positive attitude, as well as her flexibility made the process very enjoyable. She was dependable, detail oriented and her knowledge was reflected in all elements of the process. If we are ever in need of a Real Estate professional in the future, we wouldn't hesitate to call upon Sigrid Cottrell and highly recommend her to any one who is! aeromosa
View All

Connect With Me


Subscribe to my newsletter...

* fields are required

house realtor mls

Real Estate Websites by iHOUSEweb iconiHOUSEweb | Admin Menu